Teachers are leaving the profession in large numbers, so much so that this has been called “The Great Resignation.”
As a teacher with a forty-year education career, let me state emphatically that there is NO TEACHER SHORTAGE! There is NO SHORTAGE of experienced, qualified, caring, passionate teachers who want to teach and be allowed and supported in doing so. For most, teaching is not just a job but a calling and vocation. There IS a shortage of respect and proper compensation for teachers.
Several trends and figures indicate significant teacher attrition:
In Alberta, 40% of new teachers will leave the profession within five years.
Quebec recently reported a shortage of 8,558 teachers, including 1,859 full-time and 6,699 part-time positions.
A Canada-wide survey found that teacher attrition rates vary from 3% to almost 30% in the first few years of service.
In Ontario, the teacher shortage has widened. In 2021, fewer than 400 unemployed early-career Ontario graduates were estimated to be available for teaching jobs, compared to more than 7,700 at the peak of the teacher surplus in 2014.
A recent survey in Prince Edward Island found that 64% of teachers report contemplating leaving the profession.
Nobody wants to be a teacher, a psychiatrist, a therapist, a psychologist, a social worker, a political mediator, or a third parent.
Teachers are leaving the profession in large numbers due to several key factors:
Work intensification: Teachers are overwhelmed with excessive workloads, often involving tasks that don’t directly benefit students23. Many report taking on extra duties to cover staff shortages, with 80% doing more work than expected due to unfilled vacancies.
Lack of support: Educators feel unsupported by school leaders and administrators, with insufficient resources, support staff, and teaching materials. This lack of support reduces job satisfaction and increases the likelihood of leaving.
Poor compensation: While not the primary reason, inadequate pay remains a significant issue. In some areas, teachers with graduate degrees and extensive experience earn less than other professions requiring less education.
Stress and burnout: The demanding nature of the job and increasing responsibilities and expectations have led to high-stress levels and burnout among teachers.
Student behaviour: Worsening student behaviour and lack of disciplinary support have been cited as reasons for leaving the profession.
Erratic Attendance: Chronic school absenteeism has significantly increased in Canadian schools in recent years, with rates varying across provinces and districts. Here are the key statistics:
- Overall increase: Chronic absenteeism rates have more than doubled since the pandemic in many Canadian school districts13.
- Newfoundland and Labrador: In 2022-23, 66% of secondary school and 50% of elementary students were chronically absent, up from 50% and 23% respectively in 2018-191.
- New Brunswick: For the 2022-2023 school year, just over 37% of kindergarten to Grade 5 children and 45% of those in middle and high school experienced chronic absenteeism2.
- Ontario: The Hamilton Wentworth District School Board saw regular student absenteeism rates rise from 3-4% in 2020 to 8-14% in November 202234.
- Manitoba: In November 2022, Winnipeg’s largest school district reported that 1 in 5 students were absent, significantly higher than the typical rate of 12-14%34.
- New Brunswick’s Anglophone School District West: In early 2023, the average absentee rate was around 2.4 days per month for grades 9-12 and 1.8 days for K-8 students34.
- Anglophone North School District: Approximately 48% of students were classified as chronically absent during the previous school year
Lack of work-life balance: Teaching long, inflexible hours makes it challenging for educators to manage personal responsibilities, particularly those with children or other caregiving duties.
Political tensions and public discourse: Some teachers report feeling discouraged by political attacks and negative public perceptions of the profession.
Insufficient inclusion supports: While inclusive classrooms are theoretically supported, many teachers find them challenging to implement due to a lack of proper resources and support.
Piling-On: Over time, teachers are continually asked to add “One more thing” to their plates. In addition to teaching academic subjects, teachers now have MANY other responsibilities:
Teachers are now asked to perform numerous non-academic tasks in addition to their primary teaching responsibilities. These include:
Marking and grading assignments, providing detailed feedback.
Hosting parents’ evenings and conducting parent-teacher conferences.
Mentoring students and providing guidance on various life aspects.
Organizing and hosting extracurricular activities.
Planning lessons and researching topics.
Attending and organizing open days for prospective students1
Decorating and maintaining the classroom.
Performing administrative duties such as photocopying, setting up IT equipment, and taking attendance.
Collaborating with other teachers and school professionals.
Implementing new teaching methods and technologies.
Planning and supervising school trips.
Completing community service projects with student groups.
Running teambuilding camps and acting as camp counselors.
Arranging for expert speakers to visit the school.
Administering and proctoring standardized tests.
Participating in professional development activities.
Addressing student disciplinary issues.
Attending required committee and staff meetings.
Supervising students during non-class times (e.g., recess, lunch).
Communicating with parents throughout the day.
Updating and maintaining student data trackers.
Recording lessons for self-improvement and sharing with coaches.
Preparing materials and resources for lessons.
And where there have been cutbacks to custodian staff time, teachers often clean their own classrooms!
These additional responsibilities often extend a teacher’s workday well beyond regular school hours, impacting their work-life balance and potentially affecting the quality of their core teaching duties.
These factors have contributed to record-high teacher turnover rates and a growing shortage of educators across many countries, including Canada and the United States.